Talmud Bavli
Talmud Bavli

Commentary for Rosh Hashanah 56:6

איתיביה נתכוון שומע ולא נתכוון משמיע משמיע ולא נתכוון שומע לא יצא עד שיתכוון שומע ומשמיע בשלמא נתכוון משמיע ולא נתכוון שומע כסבור חמור בעלמא הוא אלא נתכוון שומע ולא נתכוון משמיע היכי משכחת לה לאו בתוקע לשיר

To hear? But he is hearing! - He may think, it is merely an ass braying.

Tosafot on Rosh Hashanah

But [a case] where the hearer had intent, but the sounder did not have intent, how is that found?: He could not find to say, such that the sounder did not have intent to have the listener fulfill [his obligation] - as [this baraita] implied to him the same as that which [the Gemara] inferred at the end of the discussion: [The sounder] sounds for himself, like [the hearer] hears for himself. Hence he does not require intention.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy
Previous VerseFull ChapterNext Verse